I knew that the day would come. I had an idea what to expect. I wish it was better, but it wasn’t. What am I talking about? Disney’s “The Muppets” (2011) of course.
“I’m not crazy about it.” – Frank Oz on “The Muppets” (2011) source
Wait! Stop press! I am a puppeteer. I consider Jim Henson and fellow puppeteers some of the people who inspired me to become a puppeteer. Sadly most of those people have either passed away, or choose not to perform the puppet characters that they helped create. Of course the puppet people who may read this know where I am leading with this, but for those of you new to The Muppets I’ll bring you up to speed. I am referring to Frank Oz, the original puppeteer of Miss Piggy, Animal, and Fozzie Bear. When I read that he felt that the script didn’t respect the characters I was worried. I am okay with new puppeteers performing The Muppets, it’s the only way to keep them alive for new audiences, what worried me the most is that the scriptwriter would not understand what makes The Muppets, “The Muppets”. Sadly I was right about this.
Jason Segal says he is a HUGE fan of The Muppets. He loved watching them as a child. Yet does being a high profile fan qualify him to relaunch a beloved group of characters that have been most often considered family entertainment? No! No! No! Sure he has marquee value, but little else when it comes to The Muppets. Two examples in the film, that he wrote and starred in, are the scene where The Muppets find Animal trying to control his anger.
This scene really disturbed me. I nearly stopped the DVD that we borrowed from our public library (sorry Disney). If Mr. Segal considers this to be family entertainment, I pity his children -if he ever becomes a parent. Which makes me wonder, how can someone write a film (that is marketed to families and children) who is not a parent himself? I have given up on Disney as a producer of quality family entertainment, they haven’t produced any in decades (that includes “Lion King” which they stole from Tezuka Productions). The other scene that stood out as an example of Segal’s lowest common denominator humor is the scene that Fozzie Bear stoops to wearing farting shoes to get a laugh. Really? The Muppets were smarter than that. Even my five and a half year old son can come up with a funnier bit with very little effort.
As the DVD played in our living room, with an audience ranging in age from five and a half to almost fourty-eight, we began to let our selves become distracted from the film that we had been looking forward to watching as a family. Tiernan looked at his train magazine, Eleanor and Lara continued to watch the movie… I think. I am not certain of this because I fell asleep. The Muppets new movie failed to keep my attention.
Perhaps I will watch this film again many years from now and find gold nuggets of Muppet-fun hidden in the Disney-sludge. My wife gave me her opinion of the film as we put away the popcorn bowls, she felt that they looked like Muppets but lacked the soul that made them so appealing years ago. Maybe the next Muppets film will capture the style of humor that made the characters so memorable. I suggest that Disney hire Roger Langridge to write the script. His Muppets comic books are excellent. He understands Muppet-style humor.
I rate this film a D for Disney.